Truth in Science

Truth in Science
Biology 2 - Cambridge University Press PDF Print E-mail
Image

Biology 2. Jones, M., and J. Gregory. 2001. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Evidence for evolution

Industrial melanism in the Peppered Moth, Sickle Cell Anaemia and malaria, and artificial selection are used as an example of natural selection in action.

Problems associated with speciation are acknowledged.
Biologists believe that natural selection is the force which has produced all of the different species of organism on Earth. Yet in the examples of directional selection described on pages 72-74, that is the evolution of antibiotic resistance in bacteria, and changes in the frequency of wing colour in peppered moths, no new species have been produced. How can natural selection produce new species? Before we can begin to answer this question, we must answer another: exactly what is a species? This proves to be an extremely difficult question with no neat answer.
Homology is claimed as evidence for evolution:

Organisms can be classified according to their evolutionary relationships. In order to do this, taxonomists look for shared homologous features between living organisms. These are features which appear to have similar underlying designs, and so have almost certainly evolved from the same ‘original’ design that existed in a particular organism at one stage. A classic example of homologous features is the limb bones of vertebrates. In all birds and mammals, for example, these limb bones take the same general pattern with a single bone in the upper limb and two bones in the lower limb. You can always pick out this pattern, despite great variations in the way the pattern has been modified in the course of evolution. Such features supply strong evidence that all organisms possessing them had a common ancestor.

Evolution is seen to be the basis of classification:

Biologists classify living organisms into groups according to what can be deduced about their phylogeny (evolutionary history).
Teaching the controversy?

No alternative views to evolution are presented.


 

Quote

The presence or absence of a creative super-intelligence is unequivocally a scientific question...

Richard Dawkins (2006)

Extras

Syndicate (updates)

All All News News