Truth in Science

Truth in Science

Higher Biology

This course seeks to give students opportunities to acquire:
...positive attitudes such as being open-minded and being willing to recognise alternative points of view (p. 4)
TiS: The teaching of evolution is restricted to micro-evolution. Macro-evolution and the theory of common ancestry for all life are not explicitly mentioned, and the fossil record is not discussed. Teaching on micro-evolution is evidence based and at a high standard. Pupils may assume that as micro-evolution stands on a good evidential basis, macro-evolution is also true. Their education would be enhanced if they had the chance to examine arguments for and against common ancestry and the creative powers of natural selection and mutation.
UNIT 2 Genetics and Adaptation (Higher)
Introduction

This unit reinforces and extends the basic concepts and ideas established in Standard Grade Biology and in the Environmental Biology and Genetics (Int 2) unit. Sources of variation are examined, namely: independent assortment, crossing over and mutation. The concept of natural selection, which is by far the most important factor in evolution, leads to an understanding of the idea of speciation. Artificial selection has been so successful in producing superior strains that there is a need to conserve traditional varieties. The content of genetic engineering takes account of the Standard Grade topic of Biotechnology. The examination and interpretation of data provide evidence to support the concepts of selection and speciation. Evolution is introduced as a continuing process and the various causal factors are explained.
Unit 2: Genetics and Adaptation (Higher)

  CONTENT  NOTES  LEARNING ACTIVITIES
3 Mutation.   
i Characteristics of mutant alleles, to include random occurrence and low frequency.

 

When dealing with mutant alleles, candidates should be able to interpret data on gene mutation frequency.

 

Analyse information on sickle cell anaemia.

 

View and discuss information obtained from computer simulation.
ii Mutagenic agents.

Mutation rate can be increased artificially by chemical agents or irradiation.
 
iii Changes in the number of chromosomes through nondisjunction.
 
Examine photographs of human karyotypes including Down’s Syndrome.
iv Polyploidy: advantages in crop production.

In dealing with polyploidy, the terms triploid and tetraploid need not be known. It will be sufficient for candidates to know that polyploidy is a condition in which an individual possesses one or more sets of chromosomes in excess of the normal diploid number. In crop plants this often confers increased vigour.
 
v Change in the structure of one chromosome (duplication, translocation, deletion, inversion).
 

 

Obtain and interpret information relating to mutation from the examination of appropriate material, for example normal/spelt wheat, popcorn/podcorn cobs, normal/albino mice.
vi Alteration of base type or sequence (substitution, insertion, deletion, inversion).
The effect of gene mutations on amino acid sequences should be noted.
 
b) Selection and speciation
  
1 Natural selection.
  
i The survival of those organisms best suited to their environment.

In the evolution of new species, the effects of isolating mechanisms, mutations and selection on the gene pool should be covered.
 
 ii The concept of the species. 
Examine data on species of animals and flowering plants endemic to Scotland.
iii The importance of isolating mechanisms as barriers to gene exchange leading to evolution of new species.
 
Examine maps to show the distribution of organisms between different continents.
 iv Adaptive radiation. 
Obtain and present information on the distribution of British buttercup species.
v The high-speed evolution of organisms such as antibiotic resistant
bacteria and the melanic peppered
moth.

 
Obtain and present information on heavy metal resistance in grasses, calcicole/calcifuge pairs in Viola species or the bladder campions.
Analyse and interpret current data on distribution of peppered moths.
vi The conservation of species through
wildlife reserves, captive breeding and cell banks. The maintenance of genetic diversity.
 
2 Artificial selection.
  
i The evolution of a wide variety of crops and domesticated animals through selective breeding and hybridisation as undertaken by humans.
 
Examine information on artificial selection in, eg Brassica oleracea, cattle, dogs. Analyse information on selective breeding by means of suitable computer simulation.
ii The contribution of genetic engineering to the development of new varieties.

In genetic engineering, the importance of being able to locate genes or groups of genes on chromosomes must be known. This can be done by gene probes or by the recognition of characteristic banding patterns. Once located, endonuclease enzymes are used to cut DNA fragments and ligase enzymes are used to seal new genes into the genome of other organisms such as bacteria. Examples to include the manufacture of insulin and human growth hormone.
 
iii Somatic fusion in plants to produce
new species.

Somatic fusion is used to overcome sexual incompatibility between plant species. The technique
involves the removal of the cell walls by the action
of cellulase enzyme so that protoplasts can be fused.
Prepare and examine plant protoplasts.